top of page

Are We Making the Right Choices? What I Took Away from Trial Forge

Nov 9
9 min read

By Peter Oluwatimilehin  |  DSxHE Volunteer


Attending the DSxHE Data Diversity Theme × Trial Forge event, Designing More Inclusive Clinical Trials: From Research Design to Funding and Approval, gave me a better appreciation of just how much thought goes into making research genuinely inclusive. We often talk about improving representation in research, but what does that actually mean when designing a study, applying for funding, recruiting participants and eventually analysing the findings?


One thing I kept coming back to throughout the session was the choices researchers make. Some of these choices may appear perfectly reasonable at the beginning, but their implications can be quite different when we examine who is actually being reached and who might be missing. And I think this matters because these decisions ultimately influence the evidence we produce and how useful that evidence is for the people who may need it.


The choices we make can influence who gets included

Prof. Shaun Treweek from the University of Aberdeen provided an interesting example through the ActWELL breast cancer prevention trial in Scotland. The researchers recruited through existing breast screening services, which seemed like a logical approach. After all, these services already had access to women who might be eligible for the study. The trial attracted considerable interest and successfully met its recruitment target. However, 94.6% of the participants were White British. The discussion highlighted how differences in breast screening attendance across communities could influence who was reached through this recruitment pathway. Even the locations where mobile screening vans operated had implications for socioeconomic inclusion.


Figure 1. ActWELL participant ethnicity and the Scottish/Glasgow demographic context shown in the session.

What particularly caught my attention was the assumption behind the recruitment approach. When conducting research, we naturally think about the sources most likely to provide the information or participants we need. But what if those sources already have limitations that systematically exclude certain populations? What if an approach that appears entirely reasonable introduces a level of bias we had not anticipated? I found this particularly interesting because it shows how successful recruitment and inclusive recruitment can produce two very different pictures of the same study.


It also made me think about the level of scrutiny required when designing research. We cannot always assume that an established recruitment pathway will adequately reach the population we want to study. Sometimes, even choosing to continue with an existing approach without questioning it is a decision in itself. And there is also the question of flexibility. Between developing a research question and completing the analysis, a lot can change. Researchers may discover that a recruitment strategy is reaching fewer people from certain communities than anticipated, or that the sources they initially considered appropriate have limitations they hadn't fully understood. What happens then? For me, this reinforced the importance of continually evaluating whether our methods are serving the original research objective. An approach that seemed appropriate at the beginning may require adjustments as new evidence emerges.


Shaun also introduced resources such as the NIHR INCLUDE guidance and INCLUDE Ethnicity Framework, which can help researchers think more carefully about inclusion when designing studies and preparing funding applications. I think the broader lesson is quite important: research design involves a series of choices, and we need to understand how those choices influence who can participate.


Making inclusion work in practice

The session then moved into the practical side of inclusive research, with Dr Shoba Dawson (Associate Professor of Inclusive Research and Healthcare Practice, University of Bristol) sharing examples of interventions being explored to address barriers to participation. What stood out to me was the range of approaches being used. From simplifying lengthy patient information sheets to developing multilingual resources, involving communities in research design, and working through GP practices to reach people from socioeconomically disadvantaged backgrounds, there was considerable thought behind making participation more accessible.


I particularly liked the examples of community involvement, where people were engaged during the development of research rather than simply being approached when it was time to recruit participants. There was also an interesting example of making patient information easier to understand. A document that originally ran to several pages was adapted into a shorter, more accessible format using simpler language and images. These may appear to be relatively small changes, but they can make a difference to how people understand research and whether they feel able to participate.


Figure 2. Examples of accessible patient-facing information, including illustrated and easy-read materials.


Another important point was that translation alone may not address every language barrier. Someone might speak a particular language without being comfortable reading it, making audio, video or verbal explanations more appropriate. What impressed me was the amount of practical work going into identifying and addressing these different barriers. Shoba also acknowledged that robust evidence about the most effective ways to involve historically underserved populations remains limited. I found that particularly interesting because it reminds us that we are still learning. There is no single intervention that guarantees inclusion, and something that works well in one research setting may have a different outcome in another.


This also connects to Shaun's earlier example. We can make an informed decision, implement an approach, examine its effectiveness and make adjustments where necessary. These interventions also require resources. Community engagement, accessible materials, translation, interpretation and other adjustments all come with costs. Seeing how these activities were incorporated into actual research budgets helped illustrate the practical commitment involved in making inclusion part of the research process.



Figure 3. Real inclusion-budget examples showing how practical inclusion activities were funded.


When inclusion requirements meet practical realities

This question of putting inclusion into practice became particularly interesting during the breakout discussion I participated in. There was a conversation about a rare-cancer research proposal where the researchers had already considered several inclusion measures, including translation, interpretation and support for participants who might need a carer to accompany them. However, additional expectations had been raised during the funding review process. This brought up an interesting question for me. As more funding organisations make inclusion an important consideration when assessing research applications, how do we ensure that the expectations being set are appropriate to the research itself?


The epidemiology of a disease matters. Certain conditions disproportionately affect particular populations, while for others, particularly rare diseases, there may be limited information about their distribution across different demographic groups. So how do we strike the right balance between encouraging researchers to be inclusive and recognising the practical realities of the research they are conducting?


The discussion also reminded me of something from my own experience. In my current role within a clinical setting, I'm no stranger to training. We receive training to understand the systems and processes involved in our responsibilities, but we're also expected to develop the knowledge necessary to support and train others. And there is a question you sometimes hear when someone does something differently from what is expected: “Who taught you that?”


I find that question quite interesting. You might be getting the job done, but someone notices the way you're doing it and immediately questions where you learned that approach. Suddenly, the conversation goes beyond the result. It becomes about the process, the knowledge behind it and whether that approach was appropriate in the first place. There is a difference between learning how to perform a task and developing the expertise to understand why a particular approach is appropriate, when it needs to change, and what might go wrong even when the immediate result appears satisfactory.


This made me think about the people responsible for reviewing and evaluating research funding applications. Given how specialised certain research areas can be, how do we ensure that the people assessing inclusion requirements have the necessary understanding of the conditions, populations and methodological challenges involved? I wonder whether continuing education, opportunities for specialist input and greater awareness of the practical challenges researchers encounter could help make these assessments more proportionate.


Researchers are continually learning how to make their studies more inclusive. Perhaps there is also an opportunity for funding bodies and reviewers to keep refining how inclusion expectations are developed, interpreted and applied. I think that could make an important difference, particularly when researchers are dealing with complex conditions or populations where the available evidence is limited. After all, the goal is to support research that meaningfully addresses exclusion while ensuring that the requirements themselves are informed by the realities of the work.


Understanding the intersections

Another aspect of the session that added to this discussion was Dr Azar Alexander-Sefre's (Research Fellow, University of Aberdeen) explanation of intersectionality. People's experiences can be shaped by combinations of factors, including ethnicity, socioeconomic circumstances, geography, gender and other characteristics. Looking at these factors individually may not always reveal the barriers people experience when several circumstances overlap. I think this is particularly relevant when we consider the different interventions discussed earlier.


Someone might face difficulties participating in research because of language, transport, digital access or financial circumstances. For another person, several of these barriers may exist together, making participation considerably more difficult. Understanding these intersections can help researchers identify which populations may require additional attention and what kinds of interventions might be most appropriate.


But something else that stood out was the importance of being proportionate. An intersectional approach requires researchers to be thoughtful about which factors are relevant to their research and where their efforts are most likely to make a difference. This brings me back to the earlier discussion about funding and research design. There is a delicate balance between identifying important gaps in inclusion and setting expectations that researchers can reasonably implement. The decisions need to be informed by the research question, the population affected and the available evidence. For me, this reinforced the importance of combining an understanding of people's circumstances with good judgement about what is appropriate for a particular study.


Inclusion extends into how we use the data

Another important aspect of the session was the discussion about what happens after participants have been recruited. Shaun returned to the importance of collecting relevant demographic information, describing study populations and considering how those characteristics should inform analysis and reporting. This raised another interesting question: what happens when we collect information about different populations but do very little with it?


Knowing who participated in a study is important. But understanding how the findings apply to those participants, and where the evidence may be limited, is equally valuable. There is also a balance to maintain here. Collecting extensive demographic information or carrying out multiple subgroup analyses does not automatically improve the quality of research. These decisions need to be guided by the research question, the available data and what can reasonably be concluded from the findings.


I think this connects quite naturally with the earlier discussions. Whether we are deciding where to recruit participants, which interventions to introduce, how to allocate funding or what information to analyse, the underlying question remains the same: are these choices helping us achieve the purpose of the research? And when they aren't, are we willing to reconsider them?


Final thoughts

While I don't plan to write a grant application anytime soon, I came away convinced that Trial Forge offers a valuable template for designing genuinely inclusive research. I particularly appreciate Trial Forge's choice of approach, which considers inclusion at every stage of a clinical trial, from the earliest design decisions to how findings are analysed and reported. I feel the session has equipped me with a stronger foundation for applying these considerations in my own research.


My sincere appreciation to Prof. Shaun Treweek, Dr Shoba Dawson and Dr Azar Alexander-Sefre for sharing their knowledge and practical experiences. I also appreciate the contributions of the other attendees during the breakout discussions, which made the conversations even more thought-provoking. Special thanks to Dr Toral Gathani and the DSxHE Data Diversity Theme and Trial Forge teams for organising the event and bringing people together to explore these important questions.


I came away with a better understanding of what inclusive research demands, and one question that I think is worth continually asking: Are we making the right choices?



About the author:

Peter recently completed an MSc in Data Science at the University of East London, building on a background in microbiology and healthcare administration. My research explored patterns of recorded GP access activity across England and how data choices affect our understanding of healthcare services. I volunteer with the DSxHE Data Diversity Theme, where I am particularly interested in whose experiences health data captures, whose it misses, and how research can better reflect the communities it aims to serve. I enjoy volunteering more broadly, including supporting social housing projects with St. George Housing, and finding practical ways to use my skills to contribute.



About the Data Diversity Theme:

Health datasets often don’t reflect the diversity of the populations they aim to serve. This lack of representativeness can limit the generalisability of research, reduce the effectiveness of new tools, and risk widening health inequalities.

A partnership between Data Science for Health Equity and Cancer Research UK, the Data Diversity Theme brings together researchers, clinicians, funders, and patient advocates to co-create practical ways of embedding diversity across the research lifecycle. It is co-led by Dr Toral Gathani (University of Oxford) and Dr Brieuc Lehmann (UCL).

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page